Point

Verdens 2 førende whiskyskribenter har begge givet point på en skala fra 0-100. Desværre ikke den samme skala. Nedenstående tabel er en sammenligning af deres skalaer.

Jim MurrayPointMichael Jackson
Nothing short of absolutely diabolical0-49,5(ikke kommenteret)
50-50,5Savner balance og/eller karakter. Var måske ikke tiltænkt aftapning som single malt.
Nasty and well worth avoiding51-59,5
60-64,5Behagelig, men ikke exceptionel malt
Very unimpressive indeed65-69,5
Usually drinkable but don't expect the earth to move70-74,5Værd at prøve
Average and usually pleasant though sometimes flawed75-79,5Absolut værd at prøve
Good whisky worth trying80-84,5Markant og exceptionelt
Very good to excellent whiskies definately worth buying85-89,5
Brilliant90-93,5De helt store single malts
Superstar whiskies that give us all a reason to live94-97,5
Better than anything I've ever tasted98-100

MurrayJacksonDestilleri navnFlaske navnAlderAlk.Aftapper
90,0MackmyraMackmyra - Den Forsta Utgaven (batch 08-02)ukendt46,1
90,0LaphroaigLaphroaig Feis Isle 2011 Càirdeasukendt50,5
90,0Teacher'sukendt40,0
90,0Destilerías y Crianza del Whisky S.A. (DYC)DYC 88 
90,0MacAllanThe MacAllan 10 Fine Oak1040,0
93,090,0TaliskerTalisker 101045,8
90,0TaliskerTalisker 1986 Distillers editioncirka 1045,8
90,086,0LaphroaigLaphroaig 101040,0
90,0BruichladdichThe 101046,0
91,090,0Highland ParkHighland Park 121240,0
90,0CragganmoreCragganmore 121240,0
90,0CragganmoreCragganmore 1984 Distillers editioncirka 1240,0
90,084,0AberlourAberlour 12 Sherry Matured1243,0
90,0Islay Mist 121240,0
90,0Tobermory (Ledaig)Ledaig 121243,0
90,0Glen SpeyGlen Spey 12 Flora & Fauna1243,0
90,0LagavulinLagavulin 12, Special release 20061257,5
90,0The Famous Grouse 12 (Gold Reserve)1243,0
90,0ObanOban 1992 - Distillers Editioncirka 1543,0
90,0BowmoreBowmore 16 Limited 1989 edition1651,8
90,086,0ArdbegArdbeg 171740,0
90,0BowmoreBowmore 212143,0
90,0Port EllenPort Ellen 1978, 2nd Release (2002)2459,4
90,0Caol IlaCaol Ila 252559,4
90,0MacAllanThe MacAllan 25 Fine Oak2543,0
90,0Port EllenPort Ellen 25 Provenance2546,0Douglas Laing
94,090,0LaphroaigLaphroaig 303043,0